 |
FAQs
Jobs
Downloads
About the
Center
Support
the Center
Outreach: Conferences,
Seminars, Etc
Calendar
Contact Us
Resources Home
CTD Home
|
 |
Developing Verbal Talent
By Michael Thompson
Verbal talent is developed by new verbal experience. It will not develop
on its own, and it will not develop if the only experiences a child has
are within the childs existing range of verbal experience. More
of the same experience will not develop anything. Verbal talent will develop
when a child is thrown into verbal situations that he or she cant
do, doesnt understand, hasnt seen beforeforcing the
child to stop, think, listen, pay attention, reread, study, change. When
new verbal experience lies beyond the known range, the child must learn
new things in order to understand. It is then the child who develops his
or her own verbal talent in order to accommodate an encounter with verbal
phenomena that are new and challenging. Only verbal experience that changes
a child develops a child.
If this seems too obvious, we must recall that it flies in the mass face
of an educational culture that avoids the shock of difficulty in the name
of self-esteem; giving students things they can do, the theory is, builds
their self-esteem. Developing verbal talent in gifted children doesnt
work that way, but provides a model in which self-esteem is the accomplishment
the student feels after successfully struggling for intellectual growth.
In order to develop verbal talent, we dont give kids things they
can do; we give them things they cannot do, yet.
Classics: Mentors on Paper
Perhaps the clearest example of what will not develop verbal talent is
the age-graded basal reader. Barbara Clark wrote that: By keeping [gifted]
children in the regular basal series, insisting that they adhere to the
regular reading program, follow-up, and skill-builder activities, we often
frustrate them. This can destroy their belief in school as an interesting,
exciting place and in learning and books as the wonderful experiences
they thought they were. (Clark, 1988, p. 338)
Reis and Renzulli also noted widespread dissatisfaction expressed
by so many school personnel about the use of basal readers for high ability
students (p. 95) and described basal readers for gifted students
as boring and sterile (p. 95). VanTassel-Baska wrote that
The use of a basal reading series typically focuses too much time
and attention on mastering the reading process, particularly phonics,
rather than allowing gifted students the opportunity for holistic reading
of good literature (p. 156). If gifted students should not be reading
age-graded, vocabulary-controlled, dumbed-down basal readers, what should
they be reading?
In addition to a variety of outstanding contemporary literature, and various
kinds of non-fiction including history, biography, and books about science,
students should be reading classics. As W. H. Auden wrote: Some
books are undeservedly forgotten; none are undeservedly remembered.
It is true. The classics remain classic. They are at many levels the standards
of excellence and the enduring works that must form one strong component
in the education of high ability students. By virtue of their multileveled
excellence, and through the influence of these forms of excellence on
students minds, the classics stretch, challenge, and mold students,
changing their tastes and giving them a sense of what the possibilities
are for human expression in language (Thompson, Mentors, p.
58). In addition to having properties that will develop students
verbal talent, classics are educational in a sense that other books are
not. Classics are part of the thoughtful commerce of the world, connecting
students minds to the minds of others in every continent. Through
classics, students come to know the lovely and wondrous literature of
the world. In the classics, they will hear the song of their species,
they will encounter their context, they will discover their kin, and they
will discover a shimmering mirror of words in which they can see manifold
aspects of themselves.
For purposes of developing verbal talent, it is important to note what
Harry Passow, a gifted educator, once told me, that classics are self-differentiating.
A book such as Treasure Island can be read by many students, but it contains
telescoping levels of depth and complexity. No matter where the reader
is in verbal development, the next level of Treasure Island is there,
waiting, luring the student on to higher forms of language and idea. The
fact that one never really gets to the bottom of a great book is of inestimable
value and distinguishes such books from ephemeral literature. It also
explains why gifted children are re-readers who go back to books and work
their way into a deeper level than they have been before.
Classics are especially appropriate for gifted children because of the
recognition factor; they are both the work of gifted writers, and are
often about gifted characters. Gifted children will find classic characters
who are like themselves, who think as they do, worry as they do, care
as they do. Remember Scout Finch who got in trouble at school for teaching
herself to read; Odysseus who solved his way home to his wife Penelope;
the stubborn Jane Eyre who declined guff from her boss; Holden Caulfield
whose world required no catcher in the rye; the clever Tom Sawyer who
got his fence painted, or the Time Traveler whose friends lacked the flexibility
to understand his accomplishment?
Classics are gifted books, by gifted writers, and are right for gifted
kids. Listen to the ethical thinking of one gifted character, the little
girl Scout Finch, in Harper Lees To Kill a Mockingbird:
Boo and I walked up the steps to the porch. His fingers found the front
doorknob. He gently released my hand, opened the door, went inside,
and shut the door behind him. I never saw him again. Neighbors bring
food with death, and flowers with sickness, and little things in between.
Boo was our neighbor. He gave us two soap dolls, a broken watch and
chain, a pair of good-luck pennies, and our lives. But neighbors give
in return. We never put back into the tree what we took out of it: we
had given him nothing, and it made me sad.
I turned to go home. Street lights winked down the street all the way
to town. I had never seen our neighborhood from this angle...Atticus
was right. One time he said you never really know a man until you stand
in his shoes and walk around in them. Just standing on the Radley porch
was enough.
The altruism of this thought would be poignant from any source, but it
is more moving here because it comes from a little girl, sad because she
never gave in return to her neighbor, and who learned one of lifes
most heartful lessons by standing on her neighbors porch, having
seen him for the last time. It is passages such as this that make books
classic, that move people to read them again and give them to others.
In such vicarious ethical experiences, the feelings of civilization are
passed from the mind of a writer to the mind of a reader, and the valuable
memories of our species are protected.
Classic Words
Another reason to provide gifted children with a rich exposure to the
classics is the rich vocabulary that they nearly always contain. Guess,
for example, what book these words come from:
diffidence, placid, adhere, quietus, miscreant, quixotic, reproof, condescend,
somber, enigma, phlegmatic, undulate, sublime, resolute, strident, din,
amicable, amorous, raconteur, profound, dejection, placid, amiably, tedious,
mea culpa, perplex, impede, interpose, incisive, impassive, admonish,
aperture, avidly, perfidious, miasma, abject, portal, fain, sanguinary,
retort, imperiously, hauteur, patronize, aloof, blithe, boon, cypher,
wince, defray, genial, cadaverous, remonstrate, nether, upbraid, solicitous,
conveyance, mauve, hitherto, succulent, artifice, proffer, ardent, tremulous,
recriminate, assail, virulent, insinuate.
Could these words come from a book by Thomas Hardy? Nathaniel Hawthorne?
The answer may surprise you; these words come from James M. Barries
Peter Pan, the story of Never Never Land, Pirate Smee, Captain Hook, Wendy,
and the boys who would never grow up (Thompson, 1990, p. 9). In Peter
Pan, Peter lost his shadow, and Mrs. Darling picked it up, folded it,
and put it in a drawer. Hook told Smee to kill Wendy, and Smee said to
Wendy, I have to kill you, but Ill save you if youll
be my mother. She refused. It is a childrens book, but look
at the vocabulary. Because such diction is stripped from todays
dumbed-down literature anthologies, and because modern publishing houses
usually require authors to avoid such words in childrens stories,
the classics have become an increasingly precious source of good vocabulary
in childrens literature.
Among the most important classic words for students to know are the following
one hundred, many of which are found in most great works of British and
American literature: countenance, profound, manifest, serene, sublime,
prodigious, singular, clamor, visage, abate, allude, grotesque, undulate,
acute, vivid, venerate, exquisite, melancholy, incredulous, traverse,
repose, lurid, languid, superfluous, sagacity, vulgar, placid, tremulous,
odious, pallor, abyss, stolid, condescend, wistful, prostrate, remonstrate,
palpable, vex, amiable, perplex, portent, peremptory, somber, importune,
audible, expostulate, subtle, tangible, vivacious, despond, doleful, pervade,
pensive, apprehension, procure, abject, austere, magnanimous, oppress,
oblique, sallow, ignominy, eccentric, resolute, articulate, furtive, fain,
genial, mien, affect, billow, confound, wan, indolent, maxim, reproach,
morose, latter, conjure, retort, antipathy, alacrity, animated, vestige,
verdure, adjacent, rebuke, zenith, inexorable, livid, dilate, fortnight,
din, abash, profane, imperious, conjecture, swarthy, impute, and appellation
(Thompson, 1998, 159).
Not every classic is equally rich in vocabulary. Ernest Hemingways
books, for example, are high in humanity but low in syllables. On the
basis of vocabulary strength, as recorded in my Classic Words database,
among the strong vocabulary books that gifted middle school students should
read are:
- Uncle Toms Cabin, Harriet Beecher Stowe, 714
- Ivanhoe, Sir Walter Scott, 519
- Gullivers Travels, Jonathan Swift, 472
- The War of the Worlds, H.G. Wells, 379
- Dracula, Bram Stoker, 345
- Tom Sawyer, Mark Twain, 293
- Robinson Crusoe, Daniel Defoe, 279
- Treasure Island, Robert Louis Stevenson, 254
- Silas Marner, George Eliot (Mary Ann Evans), 216
- To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee, 208
- Peter Pan, James M. Barrie, 198
- The Wind in the Willows, Kenneth Grahame, 193
- Kidnapped, Robert Louis Stevenson, 187
- Silent Spring, Rachel Carson, 177
- The Yearling, Marjorie Kennan Rawlings, 176
- The Time Machine, H.G. Wells, 153
- The Call of the Wild, Jack London, 150
- The Narrative of Frederick Douglass, Frederick Douglass, 139
- The Double Helix, James Watson, 122
- The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Washington Irving, 120
Classic Ideas
If we want students to think, we must give them something substantive
to think about. Beyond their sheer strength as language experience, classics
confront students with a divergent cacophony of contending ideas, as expressed
by historys least restrained thinkers. Classics free students from
the insipid slumber of textbooks, and shock them to thought with the meanings
of humanitys dissident heroes: Mohandas Gandhi, Henry David Thoreau,
Martin Luther King, Thomas Jefferson, Emily Dickinson, Frederick Douglass.
Think, these voices say, think. Be free. Be unafraid. Resist tyranny.
Protect people. Create. Reject nonsense. Apply your ethics. Pursue happiness.
The classics are an intellectual hailstorm of divergent ideas. And once
students have read a sufficient number of these books, they come to expect
ideas, and to relish the thinking that ideas demand. Here is an example
of an idea from the classics. See if you can guess what book this passage
comes from:
There is an ecstasy that marks the summit of life, and beyond which
life cannot rise. And such is the paradox of living, this ecstasy comes
when one is most alive, and it comes as a complete forgetfulness that
one is alive. This ecstasy, this forgetfulness of living, comes to the
artist, caught up and out of himself in a sheet of flame...
Is this from Aristotle? From the letters of Van Gogh? From Picasso? In
fact, these words are found in Jack Londons dog book, The Call of
the Wild. London did not shrink from putting such ideas in a story he
knew would be read by children as well as adults.
Among the ideas that classics elevate is altruism, the ability to care,
which gifted children are known to possess intensely. For his care, we
love Odysseus, who rejected immortality on a lovely island with the beautiful
Calypso to return to Ithaca and face mortality with his wife. We love
Stephen Cranes youth, Henry Fleming, who trudged off to war, earned
a red badge of courage, and learned to value not heroism but peace; the
final words of the book are among the most immortal in American literature.
Crane wrote:
So it came to pass that as he trudged from the place of blood and wrath
his soul changed....The youth smiled, for he saw that the world was
a world for him, though many declared it to be made of oaths and walking
sticks. He had rid himself of the red sickness of battle....He had been
an animal blistered and sweating in the heat and pain of war. He turned
now with a lovers thirst to images of tranquil skies, fresh meadows,
cool brooksan existence of soft and eternal peace.
Crane writes that Henry Fleming had become a man, but these words describe
not the understanding of manhood but the wisdom of men and women both;
this is the recognition where men and women meet, who have seen the pain
and suffering of lifes wars, and who have come to want an existence
of soft and eternal peace. This recognition is but one example of the
civilizing and humanizing current of these books, and it is a moving example
of why a book becomes a classic.
Quality and Quantity
An ambitious program of classic literature will almost certainly have
to be partly accomplished on a home school basis, because few schools
will be able to assign the amount of reading that is necessary for gifted
kids. How much is necessary? As a comparison, my honors sophomore world
literature class in an independent school read, in their entirety, The
Iliad, The Aeneid, The Theban Plays, Dantes Inferno, Othello, Crime
and Punishment, and Cry, the Beloved Country. In addition to these, each
student individually read two world classics per term outside of class
as homework, and conducted a personal discussion with me about each book.
This works out to fifteen major titles per year, with the students typically
waiting until the last week or two to do their outside reading.
A second consideration is that many of the books assigned by schools,
such as the Hemingway and Steinbeck favorites, are poor in vocabulary,
and exert no force against the students diction limits. For this
reason too, it may be necessary to develop a home-based reading program
to supplement what is assigned at school. When the exposure to great literature
is of high quality and quantity, the result is a significant impact on
a students relationship to books.
Ancient Words Within Modern Words - Vocabulary
In addition to reading broadly in the classics, a thorough study of the
ancient foundation of modern English vocabulary is essential to developing
verbal talent. This recommendation flies in the face of current dogma
that forbids direct instruction in vocabulary and that favors vocabulary
development through the study of words as they appear in the context of
literature. Although pondering words as you find them is a fine behavior,
it is too ponderous to suffice as a complete vocabulary development strategy.
Gifted students need something faster, more academic, and more targeted
toward the Latin-based language that pervades the realm of high achievement.
I once read a research study showing that if you learned the 100 most
common Greek and Latin stems in Englishsuch as pre, sub, super,
poly, auto, or biblioyou would gain an understanding of 5,000 words.
Learning the Latin foundation, in other words, is the fast track, the
power path to a strong vocabulary. This would seem reason enough to acquire
a grounding in etymology, but once you become involved in it, many more
reasons emerge. Lets look at some of the advantages of studying
Greek and Latin stems:
- Power Learning - Because each stem appears in dozens of words
and in combination with other stems that reappear, the learning is more
powerful than learning one word at a time. When we learn pre, we have
learned part of premonition, prescient, prefabricate, prenuptial, and
dozens of other words that describe something happening beforehand.
- Spelling - One of the great benefits of the ancient stems is
that thousands of English words are nothing more than two or three stems
in a row, so to learn stems is automatically to learn the spelling of
thousands of words. Look how perfectly these words break into stems:
circum vent; mono mania; auto graph; omni potent; pseudo nym; geo logy;
post script; osteo logy; xeno phobia; ecto derm, ortho dox; and thermo
meter. Furthermore, when you spell by stems, the spelling units are
cognitive units; each stem you spell has meaning. When you know that
omni means all and potent means power, you have a different feeling
about omnipotent from someone who doesnt know that.
- Standardized tests - Like it or not, our childrens future
depends partly on their performance on standardized tests. If you examine
SAT vocabulary pages, you see that the questions are arranged in order
of difficulty. On an SAT analogies page, the first few questions are
so easy that almost everyone gets them right, but the final few are
so difficult that almost no one gets them right. Guess where the stem-based
words such as supercilious and vociferous appear? Right, they appear
in the final questions. Kids who have studied the stems will have a
chance at an analogy like sotto voce is to vociferous as...
- Micropoems - Ordinary dictionary definitions are only the surface
of what words offer. When you know the pieces the word is made of, you
see that some of humanitys best insights are captured within the
words we use. An example is the word respect, which is an ordinary word
that most elementary students could define. We might say that to respect
is to admire, to esteem, to hold in high regard. But when we look at
the stems in the word, we see re, again, and spect, look. Suddenly,
we realize the micropoetry of the word; at the moment that we come to
respect someone, we find ourselves looking at them again, in a new way.
This epiphany is captured in the amber of the etymology, and is only
visible to children who have studied the ancient stems.
- A sense of history - The student of stems knows that language
wasnt invented new in our time. Our language is a vast collection
of echoes, and we are reviving and continuing the sounds of ancient
voices with each sentence.
- Advanced vocabulary - Many of the stem-based words are big
words. Science and technology are filled with these Latinate combinations
that seem so difficult to most people, but so easy to students who have
learned what they are made of. One of the great advantages to studying
the stems is that it converts arcane erudition into childs play.
A word like supercilious, which means condescending, is easy once you
realize that it is made of super, over, and cilia, hair, and refers
to the raised eyebrow of the snob! The beauty of teaching such words
to younger students is that it refutes the age-graded vocabulary myth
that retards American education. All across America, young children
can pronounce and understand Tyrannosaurus Rex or San Francisco Forty-Niner,
but they are considered too young to learn serene means calm.
When we are thinking about language development, and vocabulary in particular,
it is well to recall Barbara Clarks words about Horace Mann and
the age grade system:
Our current educational system is built on solutions to problems that
existed in the early 1900s. Its goal was to educate the masses since
a strong democracy could exist only if the electorate was an educated
one. The very core of our chosen cultural system, even our approach
to civilization, rested on how well we could educate our citizens. In
the early 1900s, Horace Mann, a New Englander, reacted to the problem
of mass education by devising the grade level curriculum, an orderly
and progressive approach he believed would assure students basic information
and skills. All children age six would cover the first grade curriculum,
all seven-year-olds the second grade curriculum, eight-year-olds the
third grade and so on through a twelve year progressive sequence. Manns
solution to one simple problem, however, has been allowed to become
educational dogma, and for nearly a century educators have attempted
to adjust children to this inadequate system.
(Clark,1986, p. 6)
Stems for Starters
Middle school students who embark on a study of Greek and Latin stems
can begin with the following list, which consists of very common and important
stems. The key is to learn the stem and definition, not the example words.
Stem Definition Examples:
ante (before) antedate, antecedent, antebellum, anterior, ante meridiem,
antepenult
anti (against) anti-aircraft, antibody, anticlimax, anticline, antitoxin,
antithesis
bi (two) bilateral, bicycle, binary, bimonthly, biped, bipolar, binocular,
bicuspid
circum (around) circumnavigate, circumspect, circumvent, circumlocution
com (together) combination, comfort, commensurate, common, complete, combo
con (together) contract, confidence, confine, confederate, conjunction,
contact
de (down) deposit, descent, despicable, denounce, deduct, demolish, decrepit,
deplete
dis (away) distract, distort, dispute, dissonant, disperse, dismiss, dissuade,
disprove
equi (equal) equitable, equilateral, equivocate, equinox, equation, equilibrium
extra (beyond) extraterrestrial, extraordinary, extravagant, extrovert,
extramural
inter (between) international, interdepartmental, interstellar, interject,
interlude
intra (within) intracellular, intravenous, intracranial, intrastate, intrauterine
intro (into) introduce, introspective, introvert, introject, introrse,
intromission
mal (bad) malevolent, malcontent, malicious, malign, malady, malapropism,
malonym
mis (bad) misfit, mistake, misfortune, misfire, misery, miser, misdeed,
misguided
non (not) nonstop, nonprofit, none, nonconformity, nonplussed, nonchalant
post (after) postgraduate, posthumous, postscript, posterity, posterior,
postlude
pre (before) prelude, preposition, premonition, premature, predict, predecessor
semi (half) semitone, semiaquatic, semicircle, semiweekly, semiannual,
semiformal
sub (under) subterranean, subtract, subordinate, submarine, subterfuge,
substantial
super (over) supervise, superb, superior, superfluous, supercilious, supernatural
syn (together) synthetic, synchronize, syndrome, synonym, synopsis, syntax
sym (together) sympathy, symbiosis, symbol, symmetry, symphony, symposium
tri (three) tricycle, triangle, triceps, triad, trichotomy, triceratops,
trivia, trialogue
un (not) unfit, unequal, undone, unequivocal, unearned, unconventional,
untenable
Grammar: A Way of Thinking about Our Own Ideas
In a language program for the gifted, clearly it is necessary to adopt
a diagnostic-prescriptive approach to teaching grammar and usage since
these students are capable of mastering the language system much more
rapidly than other learners and in a shorter time period than is allotted
in the regular school curriculum. (VanTassel-Baska, 1988, p. 167)
Among the curricula that American education has neglected, and sometimes
discarded, is traditional grammar, which has been tossed aside as unteachable,
unlearnable, unlikable, useless, and inappropriate for gifted learners
because it is remedial and low. There are school systems in the country
where the teaching of grammar is forbidden, and teachers get bad evaluations
if they violate the prohibition.
The fact is that grammar is quite teachable, most learnable, fun, valuable,
and highly appropriate for gifted kids because it is a high form of critical
thinking about language. And language, be it recalled, is the utterance
of human thought. Sentences do not occur in nature. Sentences are manifestations
of the mind, and sentences are a medium of the mind. When we use grammar
to examine sentences, we are undertaking a profound metacognitive exploration.
Why is grammar teachable and learnable? It is easy to forget, when looking
at a ponderous grammar textbook, what a little topic grammar is. The total
number of terms necessary to acquire the useful fundamentals of traditional
grammar is about fifty terms. There are only eight parts of speech, about
five parts of the sentence, several kinds of phrases, and a few clauses.
By expanding each term into five homework exercises, we can drag the subject
on until May of every school year, but it is easy to compact these four
little levels of grammar into the first weeks of class, and usefully apply
the grammar to all of the other language experiences during the year.
Why is grammar fun and valuable? Grammar reveals to us the beauty and
power of our own minds. With only eight kinds of words and two sides (subject
and predicate) of each idea, we can make the plays of Shakespeare, or
the novels of Toni Morrison, or the poems of Elizabeth Bishop. No system,
so gorgeously elegant, could be expected to make such a language. Through
grammar we see the simple form of our binary minds; in all of our sentences,
however elaborate, we are making a predicate about a subject, and this
reveals the meaning of clarity. For each sentence or idea, I must know
both of these two things: what you are talking about, and what you are
saying about it. For each paragraph of sentences, I must know what the
paragraph is about, and what you are saying about it. For each essay of
paragraphs, I must know what the essay is about, and what you are saying
about it. A sentence, with its two sides, is a model of the mind.
Grammar is fun for many reasons, but the purest fun is that once acquired
it becomes a kind of magic lens that reveals amazing things to our sight.
A moving example occurs in Shakespeares King Lear, where Cornwall
is stabbed as his wife Regan looks on indifferently. Cornwall gasps: I
have received a hurt. Follow me, lady. Turn out that eyeless villain;
throw this slave upon the dunghill. Regan, I bleed apace. Untimely comes
this hurt; give me your arm. Regan refuses. Absent grammar, we can appreciate
the desperation of the scene, and sympathize with the dying Cornwall who
suffers the wounds of knife and wife, but with the lens of grammar, we
see more. We see the incredible clause structure. Each group of words
with its own subject/predicate nucleus is a clause. In these thirty-one
words, how many clauses are there? There are sevenseven clauses,
four periods, two semicolons, two commas. The grammar of this passage,
in other words, is bizarre, unprecedented. For seven clauses in a row,
the passage averages four words to a clause! The question is why, and
the answer is that the grammar is shifting with the plot. Four words is
all that the dying Cornwall can manage, and his sentence structure is
a portrait in pain, it is the grammar of death.
Another way to think about why grammar is fun is to ask, what is not
fun? The feeling of confusion...is not fun. The off-center feeling of
struggling with ones own ignorance to accomplish just an ordinary
thing is not fun. The private knowledge that you dont even know
which pronoun to use in your own language, this is not fun. The low self-esteem
of guessing your way through commas, and spattering words around like
a wordy Jackson Pollack, not really controlling where they will land or
why, this is not fun. It is not fun to have a peer correct your usage,
make your verb plural, shift your wrong pronoun to the object case where
it belongs, or gently remind you that your sentence is a fragment. (Thompson,
1998, p. 3)
We begin to understand why grammar is so appropriate for gifted kids.
Grammar gives kids a way to think about language, to see what language
reveals about their own minds, to think about how language makes clarity,
to think about how different authors use language in their own styles,
to think about crafting the language of their own sentences.
How does all of this pertain to parents of gifted children? First, parents
can become domestic advocates of grammar, helping their kids to believe
in it, to know the good of it, and to be willing to do the work of acquiring
it. It is difficult, if not impossible, to truly learn something you dislike,
and so we must not say bad things about grammar, such as that it is boring
but you have to do it. Second, parents can advocate and encourage their
school systems and their childs teachers to feature grammar. There
are many teachers who want to do more with grammar but who are afraid
that opposition will spoil the project. The more support they have, the
better.
Key Points and Recommendations
- Verbal talent will not develop on its own. It develops in reaction
to challenge, which is an encounter with something beyond ones
capability. To meet the challenge, a new ability must be generated.
- Classic literature presents a complete spectrum of challenge at many
levels, including the level of language, the level of idea, and the
level of meaning.
- It is impossible for most schools to assign the number of books that
gifted readers really need. For this reason, parents should prepare
for an investment at the book store, which is the best money they will
ever spend.
- Schools take different approaches to the study of vocabulary. Some
use only a whole language approach that prohibits direct instruction
of vocabulary in favor of studying words as they are encountered in
text. Gifted students need two forms of direct instruction in vocabulary;
first, they need a solid grounding in Greek and Latin stems, and second,
they need to study the classic words. It is essential that each student
have an excellent, college-level dictionary, preferably in hardback,
that contains not just definitions but etymologies, and the etymology
should be studied every time a student looks up a word.
- The negative stereotype of grammar as a tedious waste of time should
be rejected. Students must attack grammar with enthusiasm in order to
use it as a high form of critical thinking about language. This will
produce self-knowledge, appreciation of literature, and an ability to
enjoy making good sentences and compositions.
- Many of the great intellects of history have been partly or completely
self-taught. If your child is fortunate enough to be in a wonderful
school, it is a blessing, but if not, then it is not unprecedented to
take responsibility for educational accomplishment. At the deepest level,
education is an internal act, and students who understand the importance
of language can deliberately move forward into areas of challenge in
reading, vocabulary, and grammar, with the support of their schools
and families.
- For gifted children, the development of verbal talent is among the
deepest joys and most critical preparations of life, but the talent
will not develop on its own. If we support and encourage a child by
providing access to books, motivation to read, enlightenment about grammar,
and enthusiasm for words, then the child will move forward into exciting
experiences in language that will be catalysts for the development of
verbal talent, and each new strength will be a springboard to another.
In time, the child will become a young adult, who arrives at that moment
with a long background in books, and ideas, and carefully chosen words.
The talent will be developed, and developing, and it will be time for
these experiences to be transformed into accomplishments and creativity
that never would have happened if, years ago, the child had not been
challenged.
References
Clark, B. (1988). Growing up gifted. Columbus, OH: Merrill.
Clark, B. (1986). Optimizing learning. Columbus, OH: Merrill.
Thompson, Michael. (1990). Classics in the Classroom. Monroe, NY: Trillium.
Thompson, Michael. (1998). Classic Words. Unionville, NY: Royal Fireworks.
Thompson, Michael. Editors Reflections: Grammar for Gifted
Kids. Our gifted children, 47 (June, 1998), 3-5.
Thompson, Michael. (1996). Mentors on Paper: How Classics Develop
Verbal Ability. In Developing verbal talent: Ideas and strategies
for teachers of elementary and middle school students. VanTassel-Baska,
J., Johnson, D., and Boyce, L., (Eds.). Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
VanTassel-Baska, J., Feldhusen, J., Seeley, K., Wheatley, G., Silverman,
L., & Foster, W. (1988). Comprehensive curriculum for gifted learners.
Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.
A consultant and frequent presenter at system, state, and national
conferences for gifted education, Michael Thompson is President of the
Indiana Association for the Gifted, the editor of Our Gifted Children
magazine (since 1994), the creator of the Classic Words vocabulary software(www.classicwords.com),
and the author of numerous articles
and language arts texts for gifted students.
|
 |